MUNICIPAL LAW - District Court grants municipality's motion for summary judgment as to selective enforcement equal protection claim brought by sports bar:

2016-03-11 | Matthew J. O'Keefe

Category: Municipal Law

Matthew J. O'Keefe

The plaintiff sports bar initially obtained approval from the fire marshal for an occupancy level of 1,200 persons.  Thereafter, there were numerous complaints to the police about incidents at the bar and the police began to place a van and K-9 unit near the front entrance.  The fire marshal subsequently reduced the occupancy level to 540.  The zoning enforcement officer subsequently issued a cease-and-desist order to bar live entertainment with a dance floor.  The cease-and-desist order was upheld on the grounds that the occupancy level exceeded the number of parking spaces available, 179.  The Superior Court then vacated the Zoning Board's decision to uphold the cease-and-desist order.  Nonetheless, the bar's attendance dwindled and the bar went out of business.  In a civil rights claim against the municipal defendants, it was alleged that the bar was driven out of business by unfair regulation.  The bar asserted a class of one equal protection claim.  The District Court grants summary judgment to the municipal defendants, finding that the plaintiff had failed to establish that there were similarly situated individuals or businesses treated more favorably, as required to prevail on such a claim.  The court also noted that since the bar never complied with the cease-and-desist order, the court could not conclude that the entry of that order occasioned a deprivation of any property right for the purpose of the federal due process clause.  Dean v. Town of Hamden, February 18, 2016

If you have a possible claim, you will need to review your options timely. For assistance, call the attorneys at Jackson O’Keefe now at (860) 276-8100.

With offices in Southington and Wethersfield, as well as satellite offices in East Haddam, Bloomfield and Farmington, our lawyers strive to meet the needs of area residents, making getting your legal services easier than ever.  Call us now to speak with us about your case. (860) 276-8100 during business hours or 860.966.7436 any time, or email us any time at

Our Southington office: 
97 North Main Street
Southington, CT 06489
Phone: 860.276.8100
Fax: 860.621.3065


Share this:

Latest News

More Articles